Herring is a nutrient-dense oily fish offering exceptional health benefits through its rich omega-3 fatty acid, vitamin D, and high-quality protein content. Regular consumption supports cardiovascular health, bone strength, and immune function, making it a valuable addition to a balanced diet. Whilst herring is classified as a low-mercury fish suitable for most people, considerations around salt content in certain preparations and portion limits for vulnerable groups warrant attention. This article examines the nutritional profile, health benefits, potential risks, and practical ways to incorporate herring into your diet, alongside comparisons with other oily fish options.

Nutritional Profile of Herring

Herring is a nutrient-dense oily fish that provides exceptional nutritional value per serving. A typical 100g portion of Atlantic herring contains approximately 18g of high-quality protein, making it an excellent source of essential amino acids required for tissue repair and immune function. The fish is particularly renowned for its omega-3 fatty acid content, providing around 2–3g of EPA (eicosapentaenoic acid) and DHA (docosahexaenoic acid) per 100g serving—well above the European Food Safety Authority's adequate intake recommendation of at least 250mg daily.

Beyond its protein and healthy fat content, herring is remarkably rich in vitamin D, with a single serving providing approximately 15-18 micrograms, which represents well over 100% of the UK Reference Nutrient Intake (RNI) of 10 micrograms per day. This is particularly significant in the UK, where vitamin D status is often low due to limited sunlight exposure, especially during winter months. Herring also contains substantial amounts of vitamin B12 (essential for neurological function and red blood cell formation), selenium (important for thyroid function and antioxidant defence), and phosphorus (crucial for bone health).

The fish provides meaningful quantities of other B vitamins, including niacin (B3), pyridoxine (B6), and riboflavin (B2), which support energy metabolism and nervous system function. Herring also contains iron, magnesium, and potassium, contributing to cardiovascular health and oxygen transport. The caloric content is moderate at approximately 200–250 calories per 100g, though this varies depending on preparation method, with smoked or tinned varieties in oil being higher in calories and salt. Importantly, herring contains minimal carbohydrates, making it suitable for various dietary approaches including low-carbohydrate and ketogenic diets.

Health Benefits of Eating Herring

Regular consumption of herring offers substantial cardiovascular benefits, primarily through its high omega-3 fatty acid content. EPA and DHA have well-established anti-inflammatory properties and contribute to reduced triglyceride levels and improved endothelial function. Evidence from large-scale observational studies suggests that consuming oily fish like herring 1–2 times weekly is associated with reduced cardiovascular mortality. The NHS and British Heart Foundation recommend including at least one portion of oily fish weekly as part of a heart-healthy dietary pattern, aligning with NICE guidance on cardiovascular disease prevention.

The exceptional vitamin D content in herring supports bone health, immune function, and potentially mood regulation. Vitamin D facilitates calcium absorption and bone mineralisation, which is particularly important for older adults at risk of osteoporosis. Given that vitamin D status is often low in the UK population, particularly during winter months and among certain ethnic groups, herring represents a valuable dietary source. The vitamin B12 content is equally significant, as deficiency can lead to megaloblastic anaemia and neurological complications including peripheral neuropathy and cognitive impairment.

Emerging research suggests that omega-3 fatty acids may support cognitive function and mental health, though evidence remains inconclusive. Observational studies indicate associations between regular oily fish consumption and reduced risk of cognitive decline, though causality remains under investigation. Some evidence suggests potential benefits for mood disorders, though it's important to note that NICE does not currently recommend omega-3 supplements for the treatment of depression, and dietary approaches should complement rather than replace conventional medical management.

The anti-inflammatory properties of omega-3 fatty acids may also benefit individuals with inflammatory conditions such as rheumatoid arthritis, though this should complement rather than replace conventional medical management. The selenium content supports thyroid hormone metabolism and provides antioxidant protection through selenoprotein enzymes.

Potential Risks and Considerations

Whilst herring offers numerous health benefits, several considerations warrant attention. Mercury contamination is a concern with many fish species; however, herring is classified as a low-mercury fish by the Food Standards Agency (FSA) and is considered safe for regular consumption. The FSA recommends that women who are pregnant, trying to conceive or breastfeeding, and girls, should limit oily fish consumption to no more than two portions weekly, while men, boys and other women can safely consume up to four portions weekly.

Salt content varies considerably depending on preparation method. Pickled herring, a popular preparation particularly in Northern European cuisine, can contain substantial amounts of salt—potentially 500–800mg sodium per 100g serving. Individuals with hypertension or those following sodium-restricted diets should be mindful of preparation methods and opt for fresh, grilled, or baked herring rather than pickled varieties. UK guidance recommends limiting salt intake to no more than 6g daily (approximately 2.4g sodium).

Fish allergy is an important consideration, as it can cause severe reactions including anaphylaxis in susceptible individuals. Anyone experiencing symptoms such as swelling, hives, breathing difficulties or dizziness after consuming fish should seek immediate medical attention.

Histamine intolerance represents another consideration. Herring, like other oily fish, contains naturally occurring histidine, which can convert to histamine if the fish is not stored properly. Individuals with histamine intolerance may experience symptoms including headaches, flushing, or gastrointestinal upset after consuming herring, particularly if it is not fresh. Proper refrigeration and consumption of fresh fish minimises this risk.

Purine content in herring is relatively high, which may be relevant for individuals with gout or hyperuricaemia. Purines are metabolised to uric acid, and excessive intake can precipitate gout attacks in susceptible individuals. Those with established gout should discuss fish consumption with their GP or rheumatologist. Additionally, individuals taking anticoagulant medications such as warfarin should maintain consistent dietary patterns; while dietary fish consumption is unlikely to significantly affect INR levels, patients should consult their anticoagulation clinic before starting omega-3 supplements due to potential bleeding risk.

Vulnerable groups including pregnant women, older adults, and those with compromised immune systems should ensure that ready-to-eat smoked fish products (such as kippers) are thoroughly heated before consumption, due to the risk of Listeria contamination, as advised by the FSA.

How to Include Herring in Your Diet

Incorporating herring into your diet is straightforward, with numerous preparation methods available to suit different preferences and culinary traditions. Fresh herring can be grilled, baked, or pan-fried with minimal added fat, preserving its nutritional integrity whilst developing appealing flavours. A simple preparation involves seasoning with lemon, herbs (such as dill or parsley), and black pepper, then baking at 180–200°C for 15–20 minutes until the flesh flakes easily.

Smoked herring (kippers) represents a traditional British breakfast option, typically grilled or poached and served with wholegrain toast and grilled tomatoes. Kippers provide the same nutritional benefits as fresh herring, though the smoking process adds sodium, so portion awareness is advisable. They can also be flaked into scrambled eggs or incorporated into kedgeree for variety. Vulnerable groups including pregnant women, older adults and those with compromised immune systems should thoroughly heat smoked fish products before consumption to reduce listeria risk.

Tinned herring offers convenience and extended shelf life whilst retaining nutritional value. Available in various preparations including tomato sauce, mustard sauce, or brine, tinned herring can be added to salads, wholegrain crackers, or mixed with cottage cheese for a protein-rich snack. When selecting tinned varieties, check labels for sodium content and opt for products in water or tomato sauce rather than heavily salted brines where possible.

For those new to herring, starting with milder preparations may be preferable. Herring fillets can be incorporated into pasta dishes, grain bowls with quinoa or brown rice, or served alongside roasted vegetables. The fish pairs well with acidic components such as capers, pickled vegetables, or citrus, which complement its rich flavour. The NHS recommends eating at least two portions of fish per week, including at least one portion (approximately 140g cooked weight) of oily fish. Most adults can safely consume up to four portions of oily fish weekly, though women who are pregnant, trying to conceive or breastfeeding, and girls, should limit oily fish to no more than two portions weekly.

Herring Compared to Other Oily Fish

When compared to other commonly consumed oily fish, herring holds several distinctive advantages. Omega-3 content in herring is comparable to or exceeds that of salmon, with 100g of herring providing similar EPA and DHA levels to the same portion of farmed Atlantic salmon, but often at a significantly lower cost. Wild-caught herring is generally more affordable than salmon, making it an economically accessible option for obtaining omega-3 fatty acids, though prices vary by retailer and season.

Sustainability represents a significant consideration in fish selection. Herring stocks in the North Atlantic vary in their sustainability status, with some fisheries certified by the Marine Stewardship Council (MSC). The Marine Conservation Society's Good Fish Guide provides up-to-date information on specific herring stocks. In contrast, some salmon farming practices raise environmental concerns regarding sea lice, antibiotic use, and ecosystem impact. Mackerel, another popular oily fish, has faced sustainability challenges in certain regions due to overfishing, though this varies by specific stock and fishing area. Choosing MSC-certified herring supports sustainable fishing practices.

Regarding mercury and contaminant levels, herring compares favourably to larger predatory fish. Smaller oily fish like herring, sardines, and anchovies accumulate less mercury than larger species such as tuna or swordfish, as they occupy lower positions in the food chain. This makes herring particularly suitable for vulnerable populations including pregnant women, breastfeeding mothers, and young children, though the FSA's advice on portion limits should still be followed.

Nutritional differences between oily fish species are relatively modest. Mackerel contains slightly higher fat content and calories than herring, whilst sardines (pilchards) offer exceptional calcium content when consumed with bones. Both salmon and herring are good sources of vitamin D, though levels can vary by species, season and whether wild or farmed. Taste and texture vary considerably: herring has a distinctive, robust flavour that some find stronger than salmon but milder than mackerel. The texture is firm yet tender when properly cooked. Ultimately, variety in oily fish consumption is advisable, with herring representing an excellent, nutritionally valuable option within a balanced dietary pattern.

Frequently Asked Questions